Often whenever times are offered, they are provided which have twenty four hours of your few days that does perhaps not suits with that time whilst from inside the actual background. One such analogy occurs in Harry Potter plus the Prisoner out of Azkaban when Sybill Trelawney relates to sixteen October once the Saturday, even if sixteen Oct 1993 is actually a tuesday.
There are even contradictions inside the guides here. traits of a loyal woman Like, inside Harry Potter additionally the Cup away from Fire, each other step 1 Sep and you will dos Sep are given given that Mondays and you will, into the Harry Potter additionally the Prisoner out of Azkaban, Buckbeak’s trial is decided towards 20 April, but mindful parsing of your text indicates that it may enjoys happened zero later on than March.
Plus, in the Harry Potter in addition to Cup of Flames they do say the Champions was indeed chose with the Monday 29 Oct, but 29 Oct is a saturday in 1994.
During the chapter 7 of Quidditch Through the Ages, it is said that earliest Quidditch World Cup happened for the 1473. If for example the tournament are stored all the couple of years, that it problems on the report into the Cup of Fire that the 1994 Community Glass are new 422nd. In the event the Quidditch From the Years is good, the newest 422nd Quidditch Community Cup would actually fall in the season 3161, however if Cup out-of Fire excellent, the initial World Cup had been stored when you look at the 306.
Historic difficulties [ ]
Whilst show, with regards to the schedule produced from the fresh Chamber from Secrets reference, is decided regarding nineties, new show usually looks like it’s set in the latest later nineties so you can mid-2000s, around concurrent to your publication of one’s courses. In the Harry Potter and also the Half-Bloodstream Prince, Cornelius Fudge uses a male pronoun to refer towards the “predecessor” of your Perfect Minister of British. Depending on the more than timeline, this should take place in the summer off 1996, if Prime Minister are John Major, whose instant predecessor is a lady (‘s the reason very first meeting with Fudge, the publication mentions this new election, however, Big wasn’t very first chose and only took over once Thatcher retired.
You are able, yet not impractical, you to definitely Fudge will be making reference to a distant predecessor, since Thatcher grabbed workplace in advance of Fudge supposedly turned Minister getting Secret. (Regardless if it’s possible to envision a scenario where Fudge is delegated from the Minister having Secret to meet for the Prime Minister as he, Fudge, was a student in a smaller sized workplace.) Simultaneously, the fresh personality and you will reputation for the top Minister represented generally seems to much more directly suits regarding Tony Blair than just of John Biggest. A post in the Each day Post notes that Rowling was personal towards after that-Chancellor of your own Exchequer Gordon Brown (have a tendency to considered a competitor to help you Blair’s frontrunners of Labour Class, exactly who been successful him and you can turned into Finest Minister), hence she could have been attempting to inform you Blair’s worst top. If the guides was indeed set in connect having publication day away from Philosopher’s Stone, next so it experience do occur in 2002 (after Blair became Perfect Minister).
Yet not, it actually was later stated that twenty two November is actually a monday, it was at 1994
A comparable disease relates to Nicolas Flamel, who was mentioned as being 665 at the time of the fresh new earliest guide, however, Nicolas Flamel try a bona fide historic figure and you may wouldn’t reach one age until 1996, around the big date the original book is typed. The fresh new rebuttal for this is the fact that the time the newest “real” Nicolas Flamel came to be does not correspond with the fresh Nicolas Flamel of Harry Potter.
A special condition can be obtained out of Rubeus Hagrid’s period since Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It’s required throughout the collection you to Hagrid gotten you to status within this many years off their expulsion out of college in 1942. But in that scene off Harry Potter and the Cup out-of Flames, Molly Weasley reminisces on the Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper frequently overlap which have Molly’s age at school, it appears impractical that she remembers a previous gamekeeper. Yet not, it is possible you to definitely Hagrid failed to getting a good gamekeeper immediately shortly after becoming expelled, but instead come because Ogg’s assistant. This really is possible as when Harry thinks he usually feel expelled to possess flying toward broomstick in place of consent inside the first year, the guy secret if he’d be allowed to stick to due to the fact Hagrid’s secretary.
0 Comments